
A strength failure is argued over a cylinder break. A responsibility failure is argued over a sentence written months before anyone batched anything, and by then the only question left is which party the specification already named. The question of who owns a concrete mix design has no general answer, and treating it as though it does is how a durability claim ends up with two defendants and no documentation.
CSA A23.1 gives the answer, but it gives it conditionally: the mix design belongs to whoever the specification method says it belongs to, and the specification method is the owner’s choice, not the supplier’s.
What CSA A23.1 actually gives you: two methods, and no middle
There are two lawful ways to specify concrete in Canada.
A performance specification, defined in CSA A23.1 Annex J.4.2, is a method in which the final outcome is given in mandatory language. The owner states measurable outcomes, and the contractor, subcontractors, manufacturers and suppliers choose the processes, materials and proportions that reach them.
A prescriptive specification, defined in Annex J.4.3, fixes all processes, activities, materials, proportions and methods used to achieve the intended final outcome. The owner does the mix design work and the supplier executes it.
What matters as much as the definitions is what the standard removed. Before the 2009 edition there was a hybrid practice, sometimes called the common method, that mixed prescriptive limits into performance language. It confused responsibilities, and A23.1 now requires a specification to be written either entirely by prescription or entirely by performance. Table 5 of the standard sets out the responsibilities of owner, supplier and contractor for each option, and Annex J carries the detailed breakdown.
So there is no partially performance-specified concrete. There is a performance specification, or there is a prescriptive specification that the writer may not have realised they were writing.
Where the responsibility sits under each method
Two independent industry sources describe the split in nearly identical terms, which is unusual enough in this field to be worth noting.
| Performance specification | Prescriptive specification | |
|---|---|---|
| Who develops the mix design | The concrete supplier | The owner or the consulting engineer |
| Who is responsible for the concrete as delivered | The supplier, to the end of the chute: mix design, materials, batching, mixing and conveying | The owner, who assumes full responsibility for the quality of the concrete delivered |
| Who sets the criteria | A competent design authority appointed by the owner | The owner or engineer, in full detail |
| Who may authorise a jobsite water addition | The supplier’s representative | The owner’s on-site representative |
| Who arranges quality control testing | The contractor, with a certified field technician and certified laboratory agreed with the supplier | The supplier, demonstrating the prescribed mix meets the specification |
Concrete Alberta’s technical bulletin on alternate methods of specifying concrete describes the performance route as one in which the supplier’s liability covers mix design, materials, batching, mixing and conveying to the site. The Ontario ready-mixed association’s best practices guide puts the same point in two sentences: under prescriptive specifying the owner assumes full responsibility for the quality of concrete delivered, and under performance specifying the supplier assumes it.
The water addition row is the cleanest test of whether a project team understands which specification it is working under. If the slump arrives low and the person authorising water is the owner’s inspector on a performance job, or the supplier’s driver on a prescriptive job, the authority has been exercised by the wrong party and the acceptance record is already compromised. We have written separately about why slump control matters for concrete quality; the authority question sits on top of the technical one.
Why a single prescriptive line converts the whole specification
This is the mechanism that catches specifiers, and it is worth stating plainly.
Where an owner or specifier adds prescriptive limits on materials or mix proportions to an otherwise performance-based specification, the specification becomes prescriptive, and responsibility for performance moves to the owner or specifier along with it. A minimum cement content does it. A fixed maximum water to cementing materials ratio does it. A named supplementary cementing material at a named percentage does it.
The intent behind such a line is almost always conservative. The effect is the opposite of conservative: the owner has taken the mix design, and with it the performance risk, while usually retaining a specification clause that reads as though the contractor still carries it.
That is why most specifiers writing new work now avoid prescribing proportions. It is also why reading the specification for prescriptive language is a commercial exercise, not a technical one.
What the owner has to supply when performance-specifying
Performance specifying is not a shorter specification. Annex J puts real obligations on the owner, and a performance package that omits them is not usable by a supplier.
- Appoint a competent design authority and an appropriate quality assurance process.
- Have that design authority set performance criteria based on the expected placement method and the service exposure.
- Define the exposure class for every concrete element.
- State any other properties required for the intended performance.
- Define pre-qualification or verification criteria and the quality management requirements.
- Conduct quality assurance and review the reports to confirm the criteria have been met.
- Specify the sampling point if acceptance is not to be at the discharge point, in accordance with CSA A23.2-25C.
The exposure class line is the one that most often arrives incomplete. Durability requirements such as chloride ion content limits follow from the exposure class, and a supplier cannot assign the class on the owner’s behalf without assuming a design decision that is not theirs to make.
What the supplier certifies, and what it does not have to disclose
Under a performance specification the supplier’s obligations are documentary as well as technical. The supplier certifies that the plant, equipment and materials comply with the specified requirements, certifies that the mix design meets the pre-qualification requirements of the performance standard, certifies that production and delivery conform, prepares and implements a quality control plan, and provides evidence of any required industry certification. On request, the supplier shows documentation that the proposed mix will achieve the specified strength and durability.
One item on that list is routinely misread as an obligation and is not: the mix proportions themselves do not have to be disclosed. Under a performance specification the supplier owes the outcome and the evidence, not the recipe. A specification clause demanding the proportions is, functionally, a request to convert the job to prescriptive specifying, and it should be priced and allocated as such.
Testing laboratories are also inside the certification chain. Laboratories are expected to meet CSA A283 at the appropriate category, or an equivalent approved by the owner, and field testing should be done by certified technicians. Our note on how to sample fresh concrete covers the field end of that chain.
Where Alberta’s most-used concrete specification actually lands
Now the part that explains why this question keeps coming up on Alberta projects.
Alberta Transportation’s Specifications for Bridge Construction, Section 4, Cast-in-Place Concrete, is prescriptive for the most demanding class of work. For Class HPC it fixes materials, cementing materials percentages, a maximum water to cementing materials ratio and a minimum cement content in clauses 4.4.1 and 4.4.2, while also setting performance outcomes for strength, chloride penetration, air void spacing and slump retention. For the other classes the requirements are largely prescriptive.
Then clause 4.4.5 states that review of the mix design by the Consultant does not change anything: it remains the Contractor’s responsibility that the concrete meets all the requirements. Clause 4.9.7 adds that accepted batch adjustments do not relieve the Contractor of responsibility for durability, strength and acceptability, and clause 4.26 reserves the Department’s right to reject any concrete that fails the requirements for its class.
Read against Table 5, that is a prescriptive specification with the performance responsibility left on the supply side. Whatever one makes of it as a drafting matter, the practical instruction for anyone tendering that work is unambiguous: do not assume the CSA default allocation applies. Read the clauses, price the risk you are actually being handed, and raise it before the bid closes rather than after the chloride penetration result arrives.
What that does to your lead time
Prescriptive owner specifications tend to carry documentary deadlines that performance specifications leave to the supplier. The bridge specification is a useful worked example.
| Requirement | Timing, per Section 4 |
|---|---|
| Trial batches performed | At least 35 days before placement at site |
| Mix design submitted for Consultant review | Two weeks before scheduled placing |
| Aggregate analysis and alkali-aggregate reactivity assessment | Submitted with the mix design, results not more than 90 days old |
| Petrographic examination, required for HPC | Results not more than 120 days old |
| Trial mix volume | Minimum 3 cubic metres or 50 per cent of rated mixer capacity, whichever is greater, simulating anticipated placing procedures |
| Aggregate sampling, testing and mix design | By an independent CSA certified and qualified concrete testing laboratory holding a permit to practice in Alberta |
Note that the trial batch sits further ahead of the pour than the submittal does. The governing date for a project team is therefore the earliest requirement in the set, not the submittal date that gets quoted in meetings.
What to settle before you order
- Which specification method governs, in writing, for each element.
- Who holds the design authority and who will issue the exposure class per element.
- Where acceptance sampling occurs, and whether it departs from the discharge point.
- Who is authorised to approve a jobsite water addition, named before the first truck.
- Whether a pre-placement meeting has taken place; field activities should not start before it.
- What evidence the supplier will provide, and whether any clause is quietly asking for proportions.
FAQ
Who is responsible for the concrete mix design under CSA A23.1? It depends on the specification method. Under a performance specification, the concrete supplier develops the mix design and is responsible for the concrete as delivered. Under a prescriptive specification, the owner or consulting engineer supplies the mix design and assumes responsibility for the quality of the concrete delivered.
Can a specification be partly performance and partly prescriptive? No. Since the 2009 edition, CSA A23.1 requires concrete to be specified either entirely by prescription or entirely by performance. The earlier hybrid practice was removed because it confused responsibilities.
Does adding a minimum cement content make my specification prescriptive? Yes. Adding prescriptive limits on materials or mix proportions converts the specification to prescriptive, and responsibility for performance moves to the owner or specifier.
Does the supplier have to give me the mix proportions? Not under a performance specification. The supplier owes certification that the plant, materials and mix design meet the specified requirements, and evidence on request that the mix will achieve the specified strength and durability. Proportions do not have to be disclosed.
Where is concrete accepted? At the point of discharge, unless the owner specifies a different sampling point in accordance with CSA A23.2-25C. If acceptance is intended anywhere else, including after pumping, it has to be written into the specification.
Send the details, get the mix and the slot
Specification method, exposure class and submittal dates are easier to resolve before an order than after a rejection. Send us your project details – pour date, mix type, PSI, volume – and our team will get back to you within 1 business hour with a quote and delivery slot. If your specification prescribes proportions or sets submittal and trial batch deadlines, say so in the same message, because that changes what custom mixed concrete in Calgary has to carry with it on the day.
Sources
- Concrete Alberta, Technical Bulletin No. 4: Alternate Methods for Specifying Concrete
- Alberta Transportation, Specifications for Bridge Construction, Section 4: Cast-in-Place Concrete
- American Concrete Institute, Bridging the Gap: performance specifications under CSA A23.1, D. Hooton
- Ready Mixed Concrete Association of Ontario, Best Practices Guidelines for Concrete Construction


